Former State Rep. Sheila Butt, Now a Candidate for Maury County Mayor, Discusses the Importance of the Individual in Local Political Action

Apr 14, 2022

Live from Music Row Wednesday morning on The Tennessee Star Report with Michael Patrick Leahy – broadcast on Nashville’s Talk Radio 98.3 and 1510 WLAC weekdays from 5:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. – host Leahy welcomed former state representative Sheila Butt in studio to discuss her background and first Tennessee win in 2010. Butt is an independent candidate for Maury County Mayor.

Leahy: We are delighted to welcome to our microphones in-studio, a good friend for a long time, former State Representative Sheila Butt from Maury County. Good morning, Sheila.

Butt: Good morning. How are you?

Leahy: Well, I am awake and now the studio has been brightened up by your presence.

Butt: Oh, thanks so much. Thank you.

Leahy: We have known each other for a long time. Tell us a little bit about your background. When did you get involved in politics down there in Maury County?

And when did you first get elected to the Tennessee House of Representatives? How did that all happen and how long did you serve, and what were your biggest accomplishments?

Butt: I really began getting into politics … 14 years ago there was a Tea Party which began in Maury County. And I suspect that many of us conservatives started as Tea Party members.

Leahy: So that would put us back 2008, 2009.

Butt: Okay. We started way back there. And many of my friends are just freedom-loving Americans.

Leahy: I’m guessing now Trish Stickle was part of that.

Butt: Trish was part of that. Part of that. Almost the entire executive committee of our current GOP were part of it.

Leahy: They were early Tea Party folks. People talk about the Tea Party as something that started on the principles of fiscal responsibility, free markets, and constitutionally limited government.

Butt: Absolutely.

Leahy: And say, well, what did it accomplish? It accomplished a significant amount in some arenas.

Butt: I think so.

Leahy: Being involved in the creation, if you will, of a Republican party that’s active in Maury County.

Butt: Absolutely. And a Republican Party that is individualistic. We are an individualistic group. And so we looked around and we saw that our Republican Party had people in it who were really old-school people that just thought everything is about a party.

And we thought, you know, we want people to be in office. We want people to be able to represent us who are like us. So we virtually started running for offices in the Republican Party and basically became the Republican Party of Maury County.

Leahy: That’s a good success story. And, Sheila, when did you first decide that you wanted to run for public office?

Butt: That would have been in probably 2009, November, December 2010. We started campaigning and working hard. And let me say this about our Republican Party. We have grown that party. In our monthly meetings. We have about 200 people on a regular basis.

Leahy: Every month.

Butt: Every month.

Leahy: And when you started …

Butt: We probably had 15 to 20 people.

Leahy: There’s a lot of energy around … my friend Stephen K. Bannon, whose WarRoom calls it “participatory populism,” right?

Butt: Yes, absolutely.

Leahy: I think that’s a good description of it, with a focus on the Constitution.

Butt: With the Constitution. That’s exactly right. And we all do know that local politics is very important. In our state politics, if you know the doctrine of the lesser magistrate, you understand that a state can protect itself from so many things. And a mayor and a county can protect themselves from so many things.

Leahy: So you first decided to run for state rep in the November 2010 election?

Butt: Yes.

Leahy: That was an uphill battle at the time, wasn’t it?

Butt: It was absolutely an uphill battle. We had a very likable incumbent Democrat and people would say, oh, Sheila, you are just wasting your time.

They say, you know, you might have to get in one and lose one to win one. And I said, “I have never gotten in a race to lose one. No, we’ll win this race.”

Leahy: How did you win in 2010?

Butt: Because as I mentioned before, I’m a people person and I had the same people that are right in the Republican Party right now there in Maury County working with me. We knocked on every door in the county two times.

Leahy: You knocked on every door in the county two times?

Butt: Every door in our district. There was a little part of that county that was not our district, but we knocked on every door in that county twice during that election. We just knew that if we worked hard enough and people saw our faces and knew what we stood for that we would win.

Leahy: November 2010, you’re there waiting for the election results. When did you know you won – how much did you win by?

Butt: Here’s a fascinating story. I’m at the gas station. I’m standing in Spring Hill, I get a call that I have won early voting and I’m not in Columbia, I’m in Spring Hill.

When I get the call that I have won early voting, I know that I’ve won the election. In Maury County if you win early voting, you win the election.

Leahy: And so how much did you win by?

Butt: I’d say significantly.

Leahy: Ten points.

Butt: Ten points.

Leahy: And you got elected easily every time since.

Butt: Yes.

Leahy: But then you retired.

Butt: Yes. In 2018.

Listen to the interview:


– – –

Tune in weekdays from 5:00 – 8:00 a.m. to The Tennessee Star Report with Michael Patrick Leahy on Talk Radio 98.3 FM WLAC 1510. Listen online at iHeart Radio.